Merit of the Often Ignored 4g Esbit Tab

The following article is not meant to be, nor do I claim it to be, an in depth controlled scientific study on the efficiency of esbit tablets.  There are already a lot of people out there who spend an awful lot of time finding the most efficient way to heat water while on the trail.  I’m not one of those people.  Instead, I’m simply looking at the merit of using 4g Esbit tablets in place of the traditional 14g Esbit tabs.  I don’t hear a whole lot of talk about the 4g tabs and I’m not sure why.  If you look at the Esbit systems available both commercially and cottage, they all appear to be tailored to the 14g tabs.

I have heard some mention the 4g tabs are harder to find than the 14g tabs.  Maybe I’m fortunate in that two local outfitters in my town carry the 4g tabs, so I have never experienced difficulty acquiring them.  One difference between the packaging of the 4g vs 14g is the 4g tablets are not individually packaged.  With the 14g, each tab is individually packaged in a plastic blister with foil backing.  This is something I don’t care for as once you use the 14g tab, you have the extra bulk/weight of the empty blister pack to carry around with you.  Also, in my experience, the blister really seals in the controversial Esbit stink.  Some people are more sensitive than others but I notice a significant difference in smell between the 14g and 4g tabs, with the 4g really not having all that strong of odor.  This is likely a result of the off-gassing which occurs due to the 4g tabs not being individually sealed.  I do carry my 4g tabs in a small Ziploc bag which adds probably 1g of weight to my cook kit.  This protects both the tabs and my cook pot, as I stow the tabs inside my pot.

4 esbit packaging

4gram Esbit Tab Packaging

 

14gram Esbit tab packaging

14gram Esbit tab packaging

Another thing I have heard against the 4g tabs is they end up costing more per gram than the larger 14g tabs.  Honestly, I have not done the math on this, and I’m all for saving money, but I can’t imagine the cost difference is that significant and I don’t even consider it.  And I do have to chuckle when I realize this complaint is coming from some people who have spent upwards of $700 on just their cuben shelter alone.

So for this write up, I decided to do some comparison burns using 4g and 14g Esbit tabs.  What I ended up with, in my non-scientific way, is either works just fine to heat water but there are some subtle differences between the two, including smell and amount of residue left behind.  For those who have never burned Esbit, it leaves a dark, tarry residue on the bottom of your pot.  This is another complaint I have heard about Esbit, but having the bottom of my cook pot get dirty is of zero concern to me.  That’s another thing I have to chuckle and shake my head about.  If someone is going to get really bent out of shape about a dirty cook pot bottom, it may be time to stop and re-evaluate a few things.  I do recommend to store your pot in a Ziploc bag or stuff sack to keep the residue from getting on other contents of your pack.

I don’t really cook when I am on trail.  Instead I simply heat water for warm drinks or to rehydrate meals.  I purposely package my meals to only require between 1 to 1 ¾ cups water, typical is a cup and a half.  The standard for stove testing (which remember, this is not) seems to be to boil 2 cups of water but I never boil water nor do I need 2 cups.  I find my meals rehydrate just fine with hot water, not boiling and warm drinks do not require boiling water.  The only situation I can think of where you would need to boil water is to make it potable and that’s not something I am going to get into as you would need to carry a lot of Esbit and there are far better ways to treat water.

Having said all that, I did decide to use 2 cups of water for each test burn, just because.  Let’s start with the 4g tabs.  For the burn I used 2 four gram tabs in a simple titanium burner/holder.  The burner is nothing more than Ti foil (I can’t remember what gauge) with two sides bent upwards.  I have tried quite a few MYOG Esbit burners and this simple design has proven quite effective.

Ti Esbit holder with ground protector/heat reflector

Ti Esbit holder with ground protector/heat reflector

The rest of the cook kit consists of a Heineken Keg can and a Titanium Caldera Cone.

The Caldera Cone is one of the most stable and efficient systems I have ever used

The Caldera Cone is one of the most stable and efficient systems I have ever used

Burn time was around 14 minutes, that’s pretty darn good for 8grams of Esbit.  I’ve done a fair amount of experimenting with this set up to optimize burner and distance with the 4g tabs.  The total 8grams of Esbit did not bring 2 cups to a boil but it got the water more than hot enough to burn the heck out of you if you spill it in your lap or to rehydrate a meal.  I recommend the latter.

Note the shrimp eyes

Note the shrimp eyes and this is after it cooled a bit because the steam kept fogging the lens on my camera.  Or are those crab eyes?  I can never remember which is which.

Something I have noted about the smaller 4g tabs is they not only tend to burn cleaner and with less smell but also burn more completely.  There is not as much residue left in the burner as compared to the 14g tabs.

4 tray

With this burner design, there is a small amount of run off from the Esbit liquidizing as it burns.  This is also significantly less with the 4g tabs compared to the 14g.  A burner with a tray design, like the BGET will help to contain the liquid as it burns and is more necessary with 14g tabs than the 4g.

4 runoff

Here is a photo of the clean bottom of the can before the burn.

4 can before

And here is a photo of the bottom of the can after heating 2 cups water with 2 four gram Esbit tabs.  There is only a small amount of residue left from the burn.

4 can after

OK, lets do a burn with 2 cups water and a 14g tab.

ebit in tray

One thing to note is the 14g tab took a bit more effort to light than the two 4g tabs.  One thing you can do to aid this is scrape the top of the 14g tab with a knife and the shavings really help to get it to light quicker.

Love that Caldera Cone

Love that Caldera Cone

So in order to be fair with this comparison, once the water reached similar shrimp eyes (I warned you this wasn’t scientific), I removed the pot and blew out the Esbit.  Burn time was around 10 minutes.  There was quite a bit of the 14g tab left.  Also noted a much stronger smell while burning.

esbit after first burn

Now this partial tab can be saved and used again later, and it lights much easier than the unburned tab.  Note also in the photo above there is very little Esbit lost at this point due to liquid run off.

Here is the water after this first burn.  Once again, it had cooled off a bit so I could get a photo.

water first burn

So opinion on the left over tab is going to come down to personal preference.  Personally, I don’t care for the left over tab, I would rather completely consume all the fuel in one burn.

Here is a photo of the bottom of the pot before the 1st burn with the 14g tab.

can before

And here is the bottom of the pot after the 1st burn with 14g tab.

can after

Significantly more residue than with the two 4g tabs.

So I cleaned everything up and did another 2 cup burn with the remainder of the 14g tab.  This burn lasted about 8 minutes and heated the water to approximately the same point.

Shrimp eyes from second burn w/ 14g tab

Shrimp eyes from second burn w/ 14g tab

Here is a close up of the burner after completely burning the 14g tab.  It’s hard to make out from the photo but there is a lot more chunky residue left, indicating to me, a less complete burn than with the 4g tabs.

esbit after second burn

Also note significantly more loss due to run off after this second burn.  This is why I would recommend a tray type burner for the larger 14g tabs.

ebit runoff

So in comparing the 4g and 14g tabs, the differences are really not all that significant comparing burn time and amount to achieve similar results between the two.  My conclusion would be a continued preference for the 4g tabs mainly due to how much cleaner and completely they burn.  Also, with experience, I have gotten pretty good at judging how many of the 4g tabs I need for each burn, based on environmental conditions and water volume.  In winter, for example, I will typically use 2 1/2 to 3 four gram tabs to heat 1 1/2 – 1 3/4 cups water.  On a calm summer evening, I may use only 1 1/2 tabs for the same amount of water.  The 4g tabs are pretty easy to cleanly break in half as opposed to the 14g tabs.  And while the 14g tabs are scored to be able to break in to 1/4’s, good luck with that, it’s not easy.  Pack space to me is always a commodity and the 4g tabs take up much less space than the 14g, and let’s not forget the left over packaging/waste of the 14g tabs.

So in summary, what I prefer about the 4g tabs:

  • Cleaner burn
  • More complete burn
  • Less smell while burning
  • Less smell while not burning
  • Easier to dial in exactly how much you need for the burn
  • Easier storage, less bulk
  • No left over packaging to carry around
  • No need for a special burner to contain the liquid
  • Easier to light

And regarding Esbit in general, if you have never used it, I recommend giving it a try.  It is simple to use and arguably one of, if not the, safest fuels available.  I was a dedicated alky stove user until three years ago when I first used Esbit and since then, I have used it exclusively.  I wouldn’t even consider going back to alcohol at this point.  The only thing simpler and easier than Esbit is going no cook but that is a discussion for another time.

 

Disclaimer:  I have no association with any person, entity or corporation involved with the manufacturing or distribution of Esbit products, I just like the stuff.

 

Advertisements

8 responses to “Merit of the Often Ignored 4g Esbit Tab

  1. I wonder if breaking the 14 g Esbit tabs and leaving them exposed to the air for a month or two would yield the same results? That may be the next logical test.

  2. Interesting observations. I’d also like to know if this somewhat different behavior is due to the loss of some volatile substance in the esbit or something else, e.g. increased burning surface at the beginning of the burn and therefore greater heat or something (my theory; i made the non-scientific observation that the build up of residue at the pot is greater at the end of the burn time, maybe when the burn temperature decreases due to lack of fuel or to the greater distance between flame and pot, like with alcohol stoves which tend to produce more soot at greater distances from the pot)
    I’ll have to experiment with the 4g tabs as well, i am really annoyed by the additional packaging waste of the 14g ones

    • I have also noticed with the 14g tabs what seems to be a greater heat at the beginning of the burn. I would agree with your thought regarding the initial greater surface area. Later in the burn is also when I begin to notice the liquid esbit starting to flow out of the burner, so that is causing some inefficiency. So yeah, the 14g seems really good right out of the gate but as it burns it definitely appears to lose the edge.

  3. Very interesting post. I’ve converted to Esbit last fall but have only tried the 14g size. I’ll pick up a box of the 4g size.

    I’m guessing you live in the Valley based on your email address. If so, who are the two retailers that stock 4gram Esbit tablets here?

  4. I enjoyed this article. I’ve come to the same conclusions regarding esbits. I used to use 14g tabs but with the small volumes of water I usually need to heat up, I rarely need a full 14g tab (and they are tough to cleanly break). 8g of esbit is enough to heat 2 cups of water for a drink and food (sat in a koozie) in reasonable weather. The 4g tabs do indeed seem to leave less residue on the burner and on my pot. I still like alcohol burners, but it’s so easy to take what you need with esbit.

    Only problem with the 4g tabs for me is that there are usually quite a few broken in each box, which wasn’t an issue with the 14g tabs.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s